In this post for the H-CivWar Author's Blog, Lois Leveen seeks input on how to balance a desire for accuracy in our scholarship with the inevitable unknowability of the much of the past.
At a plenary session of the 2021 Society of Civil War Historians conference, Poet Laureate and acclaimed memoirist Natasha Trethewey asked Nina Silber and David Blight to reflect on the pleasures of doubt in their (and all of our) scholarly work. Trethewey's query resounded like a cross between a Final Jeopardy question and an especially challenging round of Stump the Band.
Nina Silber replied that doubt