2016 Conference: International society for the Comparative Study of Civilizations

david rosner's picture
June 29, 2016
New Jersey, United States
Subject Fields: 
Sociology, Philosophy, Ethnic History / Studies, Anthropology, Contemporary History

CALL FOR PAPERS:  46th Annual Conference of the International Society for the Comparative Study of Civilizations


June 29-July 2, 2016


Monmouth University, West Long Branch, New Jersey, USA


“The West” and its Discontents: Contemporary Challenges to Western Dominance


Since 1500, the West has moved from the edge of Eurasia, from insignificance to dominate the world politically, culturally, and economically. Since the end of World War II, its values have established the de facto “global system” of trade, economics, and preferred governance. The last challenges to these particularly Anglo-Saxon values survived bitterly-fought wars against Fascist Nazi Germany and Fascist Japan in World War II and prolonged surrogate wars against the Soviet Union ending in the collapse of their empire in 1991. The Western Global System seemed to be without challenge.


But now challenges come from all sides.


Islam, a religion whose dominance had begun a decline in 1250, is having a renewal of militant zeal. To what degree is the West at war with Islam, contrary to the repeated assurances of our leaders? How can this be thought of as a “clash of civilizations”? Can the revival of the model of the ancient Caliphate: a single religious dictatorship, replace the western Global System?



Environmental Crisis . Pope Francis has issued an Encyclical urging his believers and the world to heed the danger of global warming. He warns that rampant industrialization has created luxury for the rich nations but undue suffering in the way of pollution and misery for the poor. To what degree has capitalism, with its ethos of materialism, contributed to the environmental crisis? Can technologies address the adverse effects of environmental damage?  Can a global system of mandatory environmentalism replace capitalism without increasing global poverty?


The Crisis of Capitalism. Is capitalism really working? For whom? The gulf between rich and poor seems to be growing ever wider. Is the “American Dream” even relevant anymore? How are the cost-saving mechanisms of outsourcing and technological innovation contributing to the unemployment crisis in the US? Yet many of the world’s poor have been lifted out of poverty by science, technology and democracy in this past century. Capitalism has worked in ways that no other ideologies have managed to do. Or was much of that prosperity built on “borrowed” money and deferred payments? Perhaps the Great Recession”: of 2008 has made it painfully clear that it is now time to pay the overdue bill.


China and Russia: Challenges to the Western System.  China is a newly awakened ancient culture that has its own amalgam of the old and the new. To some degree China rejects the hegemony of the Western Global System, though it also appears to have lately appropriated elements of it to its own benefit. Russia also indicates unwillingness to accept Western hegemony. What institutions do they offer that provide better societal solutions?


Multiculturalism.   Many European countries have attempted the model of multiculturalism, admitting large numbers of immigrants and abolishing internal borders in an attempt to create a united Europe. Has this model succeeded? Can it really succeed when immigrants are not willing or able to integrate into their host country’s culture?  Is this model now under fire? Also interesting to consider are the challenges to Western culture in the realm of art and music.  As globalization progresses in the cultural realm we are seeing unprecedented cultural exchange in these areas. While non-Western music and art do not represent challenges per se to the West, they are an important part of the encounter of the West with the other. Of particular interest will be modes of cultural appropriation and synthesis. 



The Energy Revolution.  As the United States become energy independent and an energy exporter, how does that affect the Global System?   Do we still need the Middle  East?  Israel has become a water exporter in the Middle East, the only country with technologies dealing with water. How does this affect the relationships in that region and the Global System?



  • Decadence and Moral Decay: The Challenge from Within. Why are so many people in the US 100 times more interested in the latest cell-phone app, online video game or “reality TV” distraction, than they are about the urgent issues facing civilization today? Was Spengler right about the "Decline of the West", not only in terms of the political or economic spheres, but in a spiritual sense as well?  What are the implications of this for civilizational study?



The world is changing at a rapid pace. How are we to understand these challenges to Western hegemony?  What are the positives and what are the negatives?


Papers are invited on the above topics, and any other topics of civilizational relevance. 


Please send abstracts by April 15 to Program Chair, Dr. Laina Farhat-Holzman