Energy transitions: environmental and social stakes

Christophe Roncato Tounsi's picture

Your network editor has reposted this from H-Announce. The byline reflects the original authorship.

Call for Papers
October 10, 2019 to October 11, 2019
Subject Fields: 
American History / Studies, Canadian History / Studies, Environmental History / Studies, Geography

Energy transitions:

environmental and social stakes

International colloquium, Grenoble Alpes University

October 10-11 2019

 Research center: ILCEA4

Susanne Berthier Foglar, Professor, Grenoble Alps University.

Christophe Roncato Tounsi, Senior Lecturer, Grenoble Alps University.


Keynote :

Stephanie Pincetl,  PhD, Founding Director and Professor-in Residence California Center for Sustainable Communities, UCLA.



If the term transition can already be found in the works of 19th century and early 20th century writers such as Auguste Comte and Emile Durkeim, the concept of transition has become a canonical term at the end of the 1990s and in the early 2000s (L’Âge de la transition, Bourg, Kaufman, Méda, 2016). The Transition Town Movement which grew out of the grassroots mobilization of Rob Hopkins is one striking example. The popularity of the term and of the concept of transition had Belgium philosopher Pascal Chabot say recently that it expresses « the zeitgeist of our time ».


The multiple environmental problems that we face in the 21st century have been persuading a growing number of individuals, of cities and States to question and redefine their relationship to the natural world. The advocates of the energy transition strive to put an end to fossil fuels and to ramp up renewable energies. In the US at least 80 cities, five counties and two States have pledged to commit to 100 % renewable energy by 2045. Six cities (Aspen, Burlington, Georgetown, Greensburg, Rock port and Kodiak Island) have already reached this goal. The work of Mark Z. Jacobson and his Stanford University team confirms the feasibility of this transition. Their studies (2015, 2017, 2018), which develop road maps at the local, regional and national level, have shown how 139 countries (2017) and 53 cities (2018) can transition to 100 % renewable energies by 2050.


The energy transition is usually presented in a positive way : renewable energies are clean, sustainable, job-creating and have a positive impact on our health and on the environment. This gives rise to an optimistic and enthusiastic narrative which opens up the field of possibles to individuals, organizations and institutions who are nonetheless conscious of the challenges that lie ahead. Life Cycle Analyses comfort these narratives. A recent study shows that in terms of pollution there is no match between fossil fuels and renewable energies : “Replacing fossil fuel power plants with renewable energy sources, including solar, wind, hydropower and geothermal power, would reduce diverse types of pollution. The magnitude of difference in pollution between fossil and some renewable energy options is stunning.” (Gibon, Hertwich, Arvesen, Singh, Verones, 2017). Because the results of this study do not stand alone, we can safely conclude that the social and environmental benefits of renewables are important.


Yet, this positive discourse tends to leave behind a whole segment of the energy transition. The example of Rare Earth Elements, these materials used notably in the green-tech industry, is telling : “Currently, rare earths elements are mined and processed in ways that generate tremendous harm to surrounding environs and their inhabitants… Cancers, birth defects, and the decomposition of living people’s musculoskeletal systems: these constitute an epidemiological crisis affecting some two million people in northern China…Southern California, Malaysia, and Central Asia.” (Julie M. Klinger, Rare Earth Frontiers, 2017) Furthermore, the work of French environmental historian Jean-Baptiste Frezzoz shows that there has never been such a thing as an energy transition in history (i.e. entirely giving up one source of energy for another), but that societies have rather accumulated various sources. In this respect, Frezzoz is skeptical about a total transition towards renewables and insists on the fact that leaving fossil fuels in the ground represents an unprecedented challenge. The advocates of the energy transition do not take into account the whole socio-environmental narrative and only focus on the successes of the transition. This gap in their analysis forms a breeding ground for adverse forces who have no interest in transitioning and facilitates criticism.


The gap between these two narratives opens up a space of dialogue which this conference proposes to address by investigating the multiple social and environmental stakes behind the energy transition.


If the organizers themselves mostly specialize in history and environmental history, we would like to encourage scholars from different disciplines to send their proposals: history and environmental history, urban planning, geology, sociology, philosophy, geography, economy, etc. The scientific committee will particularly, yet not exclusively, welcome papers addressing some of the following issues:


- Transition towns

- Transition policies

- Energy transition and environmental justice

- Indigenous peoples and the mining industry

- Social movements and their modes of action

- Transition and natural resources

- The concept of transition in history

- The discourses of transition

- Mining industries

- Transition workers

- High-tech and low-tech

- Energy transition and the economy

- Mining environmental disasters

- Energy transition and environmental law

Selective bibliography:

Dominique Bourg, Alain Kaufmann, Dominique Méda. L’Age de la transition. En Route vers la reconversion écologique. Les Petits matins/Institut Veblen, 2016.

Philippe Frémeaux, Wojtek Kalinowski, Aurore Lalucq. Transition écologique, mode d’emploi. Les Petits matins, 2014.

Rob Hopkins. Transition Companion: Making your community more resilient in uncertain times. Green Books, 2016.

Andrew C. Isenberg. Mining California. An Ecological History. Hill and Wang, 2005.

Mark Z. Jacobson. Air Pollution and Global Warming: History, Science, and Solutions, 2nd Edition, Cambridge University Press, 2012.

Julie Michelle Klinger. Rare Earth Frontiers. From Terrestrial Subsoils to Lunar Landscapes. Cornell University, 2017.

Pierre Lamard, Ncolas Stoskopf (dir.). La Transition énergétique. Un concept historique ? PUS, janvier 2019.

J.R McNeill, George Vrtis. Mining North America. An Environmental History since 1522. University of California Press, 2017.

Guillaume Pitron. La Guerre des métaux rares. La Face cachée de la transition énergétique et numérique. Les Liens qui libèrent, 2018.

Paolo Pombeni (dir.). The Historiography of Transition. Critical Phases in the Development of Modernity (1494-1973), New York, Routledge, 2016.

Robert Pollin. Greening the Global Economy, MIT Press, 2015.

Varun Sivaram. Taming the Sun. Innovations to Harness Solar Energy and Power the Planet. MIT Press, 2018.

Vaclav Smil. Energy and Civilization. A History. MIT Press, 2017.


Organizing committee :

Susanne Berthier Foglar, Professor at Grenoble Alpes University.

Christophe Roncato Tounsi, Senior Lecturer at Grenoble Alpes University.

Administration of colloquium:

Houria El Mansouri,

Scientific committee :

Roy Carpenter, Senior Lecturer at Grenoble Alpes University, american law, environmental studies.

Blake Hudson, Professor of Law, University of Houston Law Center Faculty, Professor of Law
A.L. O'Quinn Chair in Environmental Studies.

Ann Einsenberg, Assistant Professor of Law, University of South Carolina

André Dodeman, Senior Lecturer at Grenoble Alpes University, Canadian and environmental studies.

Jean-Daniel Collomb, Senior Lecturer at Lyon 3 University, US history, history of American environmental movements.

Françoise Besson, Professor at Toulouse Jean-Jaurés University, British, Canadian and Native American literatures, travel writing, ecocriticism.

Yves-Charles Grandjeat, Professor at Bordeaux 3 University, 20th American literature, nature writing, environmental literature, American art.

Mokhtar Ben Barka Professor at Valenciennes University, specialist of religion in the US, evangelical Protestantism, fundamentalism, televangelism, American far-right politics.

Waiting for an answer : François Duban, Professor at Reunion University, north-American environmental studies.


Communication proposals are to be sent as abstracts (300-400 words) to and, with a brief bio-biblio note (5-6 lines) before May 2 2019. Please indicate a professional e-mail address and your university of affiliation. Feedback from the scientific committee will be sent by May 20.



Contact Info: 

Communication proposals are to be sent as abstracts (300-400 words) to and, with a brief bio-biblio note (5-6 lines) before May 2 2019. Please indicate a professional e-mail address and your university of affiliation. Feedback from the scientific committee will be sent by May 20.