fte-ep1-adviceforfirst-timereviewers.mp3
Loading Video...
Description:
Feeding the Elephant Podcast
Produced by Yelena Kalinsky
Music by Kakia Gkoudina
Episode 1 features
Robert Cassanello, Associate Professor of History, University of Central Florida
Saul Noam Zarritt, Associate Professor of Yiddish Literature, Harvard University
Kathleen Fitzpatrick, Director of Digital Humanities and Professor of English, Michigan State University
5 Replies
Elif Sendur
This episode is so useful. I wish there were links to peer review rubric samples but still , this is so informative.
Heng Du
Would this become available through a Podcast app by chance?
Yelena Kalinsky
Dear Heng Du,
Thanks for listening! It is not as yet available on a podcast feed, but if we find a way to do that, I'll post it here.
And Elif asked about links to sample peer review rubrics. I don't know of any off the top of my head, but I would suggest looking at the materials on the COPE (Committee on Publication Ethics) website: https://publicationethics.org/. There, they have lots of practical, detailed information on peer review processes, ethical guidelines, etc. Perhaps Feeding the Elephant readers can point to some examples of publicly available peer review rubrics.
All the best,
Yelena
Heng Du
Many thanks Yelena!
Stacy Fahrenthold
This is so helpful, thank you! I especially love how concise it is. I am working with grad students as they prepare to do a mock peer review assignment, and this is a perfectly assignable piece.